Monday, September 10, 2012

FAIL | Homemade Apple Cider Vinegar

Awhile back I had this lovely goal of using up all of the apples which were given to us...and I mean using EVERY PART I COULD. In attempt to use the peels and cores I read a lot of articles about making Homemade Apple Cider Vinegar. After reading the articles I felt like it was a no-brainer and would be super easy. Boy was I wrong!

August 7th marks the first day I started the Homemade Apple Cider Vinegar project. I put peelings and cores from the apples I had already used into jars. Covered the cores/peels with fresh water and then covered each jar with cheese cloth secured by rubber bands. The project looked beautiful and I was so excited!

The 4 jars where it is dark on the cheese cloth is because the water spilled on it when I was taking it downstairs for storage.

Throughout the next few days I added a few more jars of apple peels and cores to the collection. In the end it totaled 12 jars. I was still hopeful of this project turning out well.

About two weeks into the project I noticed a terrible problem. There was a huge swarm of gnats surrounding my vinegar!! :( Ugh. They are so gross. Why were they created?? The vinegar still smelled/looked fine at this point so I left it alone. Mom bought gnat traps a week later and we started catching a ton of the gnats on them.

Well today was "the revealing" of the vinegar. I carried all the jars outside and got everything ready for opening them and storing what I thought would be the vinegar into a gallon jug. I was feeling excited until I opened the first jar (aka removed the cheese cloth and rubber band) and discovered that the apple cores which were above the water looked funky. Almost like there were little baby larva living on/in it.

Yuck, yuck, yuck.

I quickly uncovered the remaining jars to find all the jars with just cores (I did some just cores and some just peels to experiment) covered in these disgusting things. I was sickened just looking at them. (The vinegar with just peels smelled rancid so I threw it out too...I was to grossed out by the whole project to even consider keeping ANY of it.)

After draining each jar into a large bowl, I threw all the cores, cheesecloth, and rubber bands into a triple sacked WalMart bag. That went directly to the dumpster after everything was drained. The would-be vinegar was dumped very far away from the house: behind the shed. The jars were washed outside in very hot soapy water and then brought in to run through the dishwasher.

I am very disappointed in how terrible this project went. It was disgusting in the end and it is one thing I never plan to try and attempt in the future. I am grateful to all the poor people in this house who had to put up with the gnats and smell of vinegar and then the rotten vinegar. They were very cooperative even though it was terribly unpleasant. I am making a cake tonight in one attempt to say I'm sorry....this was a truly large fail and I don't plan to repeat it.


  1. Awww...those things happen. You will come up with something else terrific and this project will be just a vague memory! :o)

  2. EW! I wonder what went wrong? At least there will be cake! LOL.

    -Daisy Nguyen from PS BANANAS fashion blog:

    1. Yeah it was pretty gross! And the cake is actually gonne be made another day but it will be a new recipe post!


  3. Awww. Even though I'm over here laughing, I feel bad for your misery. :( Sorry it didn't turn out at all. But I have learned from your lesson on what not to do if I try to make the stuff.

    1. Oh I am very sure you are laughing! lol. I miss seeing you!



Thanks for stopping and leaving a comment! I LOVE reading comments! {They also help me know what you are interested in reading on my blog!}

Comments on posts older than 14 days are moderated. Other comments may be removed if they are inappropriate or spam. I do read all comments but can't always respond to each one because I don't get online very often.

My email can be found on my 'about me' page if you would like to contact me or you have a question.